When Physical Therapy Becomes Too Much of a Good Thing
In orthopedics, physical therapy (PT) has become almost sacred. If you have surgery, you go to PT. Surgeons prescribe it, insurance companies expect it, and patients are told it’s the key to recovery. And to be clear—physical therapy is incredibly important in post-operative recovery. Most surgeons rely on it to restore motion, rebuild strength, and ultimately determine the success of many procedures.
But here’s the controversial question no one seems eager to ask:
What if we’re prescribing too much of it?
The Evolution of Post-Operative Rehab
Over the years, rehabilitation science has improved dramatically. We’ve learned that early movement is often better than prolonged immobilization. We’ve discovered exercises that stimulate muscle hypertrophy more efficiently. We’ve also identified movements that should be avoided entirely after certain procedures.
Because of this growing knowledge base, the role of PT in recovery has expanded. Insurance companies cover it more frequently, surgeons prescribe it more aggressively, and rehabilitation protocols continue to evolve.
In many cases, this progress has been a good thing. Patients who previously might have struggled alone now have structured guidance and support.
But in other cases, we’ve swung the pendulum too far.
The Rise of Physical Therapy Overload
A study published in the Turkish Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation found that patients attending physical therapy two days per week actually showed greater improvement than those attending five days per week.
Think about that for a moment.
More therapy didn’t lead to better outcomes. In fact, less therapy produced better results.
In practice, I’m seeing something similar. Patients who were not particularly active before their injury or surgery are suddenly being pushed into extremely demanding rehab schedules. They’re attending PT two days per week and then completing home exercise programs three or four additional days per week.
That’s essentially five to six days of rehab every week.
A Simple Thought Experiment
Let’s imagine a patient who exercised maybe once a week before surgery—if that.
Now we take that same person, repair a tendon or ligament, and tell them to start exercising that same body part five or six days per week.
What would happen to a healthy person under that kind of sudden workload increase?
They’d develop soreness, inflammation, and fatigue. Their performance would decline. They’d struggle to recover between sessions.
Now add surgical trauma on top of that.
Yet we’re surprised when patients plateau or develop persistent pain.
The 3–4 Month Frustration Point
I hear the same thing from patients over and over again around the three- to four-month mark:
“I’m doing all my PT exercises. I have good motion. But it still hurts and I don’t understand why.”
Often, the answer is simple.
They’re doing too much.
We are asking recovering surgical patients to perform a level of consistent training that we wouldn’t even prescribe to many healthy individuals. The body doesn’t just need movement to heal—it also needs rest, recovery, and adaptation time.
When those are missing, progress stalls.
The Checklist Problem
Another issue is how we measure success.
Too often recovery gets reduced to a checklist of tests and milestones. Push-ups. Strength scores. Range-of-motion benchmarks.
But let’s be honest: if a patient couldn’t do a push-up before surgery, why are we using push-ups as the metric for success after surgery?
Because a protocol says so?
Because a testing sheet requires it?
That kind of thinking ignores the most important part of medicine:
The patient as a whole person.
It’s Time to Re-Evaluate
None of this means physical therapy isn’t valuable. It absolutely is. In many cases, it’s the difference between a successful outcome and a poor one.
But more therapy isn’t always better therapy.
Maybe we need to step back and ask some uncomfortable questions:
- Does every patient truly need the same volume of rehab?
- Are we pushing recovery timelines simply because protocols tell us to?
- Are we asking patients to perform at levels they never reached before surgery?
Healing isn’t a race.
Sometimes the most effective thing we can do for a patient isn’t pushing them harder.
Sometimes it’s giving the body the time and space it needs to recover.
And maybe the most controversial idea of all is this:
Better rehab isn’t always about doing more. Sometimes it’s about knowing when to do less.
Leave a Reply